The Desk, the Test, the LMS: The 5 Spaces for (re)Design in Education

by | Thursday, November 30, 2023

What do a teacher’s desk, the PISA test and Learning Management Systems (LMS) have in common. Apart from being educational technologies, they are also the heart of a book chapter that Melissa Warr, Kevin Close and I just published in a book titled Formative Design in Learning: Design Thinking, Growth Mindset and Community.

In this chapter we argue that everything around us is designed – often intentionally, sometimes not. In an educational context this includes curricula, classroom layouts, and testing systems. Further we argued that seeing education as an artificial system gives us the power to redesign it for the better. Seeing schooling as an intentional design highlights that things don’t have to be the way they are. If standardized testing promotes unhealthy competition or learning management systems limit creativity, we can recreate them.

In this paper we also build on our previous work on the 5 spaces for design in education framework suggesting that it design in education focuses on 5 key spaces: artifacts, processes, experiences, systems and culture. For example, a teacher’s desk is an artifact, grading papers is a process, taking a standardized test is an experience, degree programs are a system, and beliefs about the role of technology in learning shape culture.

In this piece we illustrate how these spaces intersect through an analysis of the three above-mentioned educational technologies: the teacher’s desk, the PISA standardized test, and learning management systems. We highlight how the physical placement of a teacher’s desk can shape classroom roles and culture, and critique how the PISA test reflects and reproduces beliefs that students are economic resources. And, finally, we imagine how redesigning rigid learning management systems could better support networked, social learning models. Thorough this process we seek to reveal how educational designs are interconnected, opening up possibilities for reimagining education. What other ubiquitous designed elements in education deserve a deeper look? How might we redesign them? Read the full article to learn more about this perspective on education and design.

Complete citation and abstract given below:

Warr, M., Close, K., & Mishra, P. (2023). What Is Is Not What Has to be: The Five Spaces Framework as a Lens for (Re)design in Education. in B. Hokanson, M, Schmidt, M. E. Exter, A. A. Tawfik, & Y Earnshaw (Eds.) Formative Design in Learning: Design Thinking, Growth Mindset and Community. Educational Communications and Technology: Issues and Innovations. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-41950-8_24

Abstract: Design is everywhere. Recognizing how everything in education is designed, including systems and cultures, increases our agency to make changes on those designs. In this chapter, we introduce the five spaces framework which pro- vides an analytical tool for understanding the relationships among designed entities, shifting perspectives and offering new possibilities for (re)design. To illustrate the framework, we analyze three technologies in education: the teacher’s desk, PISA test, and learning management systems.

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Creativity in Las Vegas

I was recently invited to present a keynote address at the 21st Century Instructional Technology Conference (titled Elements of Technology) at the Clark County School District in Las Vegas, Nevada. Clark County is the 5th largest school district in the country with...

Two new photosets

I just uploaded two new photosets onto to Flickr. They are: Best of 2007 A photoset documenting the past 12 months (mostly family related stuff) Matt & Punya There was a recent article in the New Educator about the work Matt and I do together (the TPCK stuff). Here...

The beauty of randomness

The beauty of randomness

I have always been intrigued by the idea of how truly random our lives really are. Seemingly minor events can trigger effects, rippling through our lives, effects becoming causes, leading to profound changes and transformations. Ray Bradbury's short...

Off to India

I am heading off to India tomorrow and will be gone for approximately two weeks. The main reason for this trip is to attend the International Conference on Indian Education: The Positive Turmoil in New Delhi. I am scheduled to present and act as a resource person for...

ON@TCC: Do not toss aside lightly…

One Night at the Call Center is the second novel by Chetan Bhagat. I picked it up from the library, since I had read nice things about it on some website somewhere. What a tragic waste of time. This is a terrible novel - maybe the worst I have read in a long, long...

Unpacking Design & Creativity @ Purdue

The presentation Unpacking Design and creativity: What I think I know, and what I (quite certainly) don't is done, and it went well (I think). You can read the abstract here or view the presentation below Or see it full screen, by clicking here. After the presentation...

The Five Spaces for Design in Education

The Five Spaces for Design in Education

Note: This post was co-authored with Melissa Warr. I love to talk about design and education. I like to hang out with people who care about design and education. This brings us to TalkingAboutDesign.com, a website/blog created by a group of graduate students (and...

Pi(e) day, 2019

Pi(e) day, 2019

A design created in celebration of Pi-day, 2019. (More context about the day here and more about the number itself here). As always, the OofSI team celebrates Pi(e) day by offering a selection of Pi(e)'s - exactly at 1:59 PM. Totally irrational I know! Apart from...

TPACK survey, new journal article

Hot off the press: Schmidt, D. A., Baran, E., Thompson, A. D.,  Mishra, P.,  Koehler, M.J. & Shin, T. S. (2010). Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK): The development and validation of an assessment instrument for preservice teachers. Journal of...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *