TPACK & Philosophy

by | Tuesday, May 30, 2023

I often receive emails about the TPACK framework and even though I have not worked in that space for a while, I do feel obligated to respond. That said, I usually do not feel the need to document my responses. Once in a while, however, I get a question that demands a thoughtful, extended response.

This afternoon I received the following email (included below with permission and rewritten to not provide any information of the identity of the person who had sent it).

I am a high school philosophy teacher (covering content all the way from Plato to Nietzsche). I’ve been reading about the TPACK framework but am unsure about how to apply it to teaching philosophy. Are there specific examples or ideas to implement TPACK within philosophy education? 

This is how I responded:

Thank you for writing to me. 

Let me begin by saying that I am not any kind of expert on philosophy. I have never formally taken a class in it – ever. That said, have over the years, on my own read a lot, but it is scattershot driven by my immediate interests rather than any kind of systematic approach. 

But onto your question… 

The TPACK model suggests that there needs to be an integration of technology, pedagogy and content. What you have told me is that the content is philosophy – but that is not enough. What do you want your students to take away from the class? Should they know what philosophers have said about various topics or do you want them to engage in philosophical argumentation with questions that are important to them? Or some combination of that? Are you interested in their better understanding philosophical argumentation about topics, such as nature of knowledge, how we make meaning of the world, the role of god, or how we lead a ethical life? Or are you interested in their connecting what philosophers have said to their own teen-age contexts or maybe even global challenges we face? 

The second set of questions would be about what your pedagogical approach is? Do you prefer lectures or are students engaged in reading primary texts and seeking to understand the ideas through writing and discussion? Do you like your students to debate each other taking on specific historical roles? Or do they take the ideas they learn and speak to others to better understand how these ideas play out in the real world? 

I could go on. 

The point is that in each of these situations there are certain technologies that are better suited to intersection of the content and the pedagogical approach. If the case is philosophical argumentation then collaborative writing tools, or discussion forums, maybe the way to go? If it is capturing the ideas of specific philosophers – it may be about creating video profiles of the philosophers, their historical context and so on by doing research on the internet (from validated sources). If the idea is how people reflect on certain philosophical concerns with respect to their own lives – maybe some kind of interview format, with people on the street, may make sense. 

Again I could go on. 

I think the broader point is that there are many ways of looking at content and pedagogy – that I am sure you as an experienced teacher have clear views on. I would start from there, what do you care about and how do you go about doing it? And it is only then you can investigate what technological tools best fit what you need to achieve. 

Let me also add, that you are most probably already using technology in your classroom – for instance I am sure students are reading books and articles. You may already be using online resources such as The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy or others. So you are already using the TPACK framework. There is nothing magical about it. 

That said, sometimes new tools give us new opportunities. For example I recently experimented in using Bing Chat (a form of generative AI similar to ChatGPT) to “generate” a conversation between two educational philosophers, John Dewey and Jiddu Krishnamurty about how their ideas applied to learning with technology. You can read it here: Krishnamurti and Dewey in the metaverse. Is this valuable? I don’t know since I don’t know what your goals are. 

But I think good use of TPACK comes from reflecting on what you want your students to take away, how you orchestrate that – and what tools you would use to get them there. Context matters – greatly. 

I hope this helps. 

~ punya

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Jabberwocky goes to graduate school

The 5th floor of Erickson Hall is a fun place to be. Typically a bunch of graduate students hang out there, working on their readings, talking shop and in general having a good time. For some reason, last week, I promised Josh Rosenberg that I would write a poem for...

On making computation visible

Here is a cool video about a "a mechanical, binary adding machine that uses marbles to flip the bits" - in other words a computer made of wood, that works at a pace that we can grasp! Marvelous. (HT: Collision Detection). Check out the video: [youtube width="425"...

Meta poems too

Meta poems too

Layout is the first to go Lines of poetry are sacred to both the author and the reader. To alter the specific construction in line length is to alter the look and rhythm of the poem. However, as ebooks and eReading devices have become more prevalent, readers have come...

Many Voices, One Song: Orchestrating Polyphonic Learning

Many Voices, One Song: Orchestrating Polyphonic Learning

In music, polyphony describes a texture where multiple independent melodic voices interweave to create something greater than the sum of its parts. The philosopher Mikhail Bakhtin expanded this idea to human discourse, seeing it as a way for multiple voices and...

John McCain, RIP

John McCain, RIP

• • • • • • • • •John Sidney McCain IIIAugust 29, 1936 – August 25, 2018 The above image is a visual / typographic representationof one his favorite quotesfrom For whom the bell tolls,by Ernest Hemingway Image © punyamishra

Photos from the AT&T Award ceremony

The award ceremony for the 2008 MSU-AT&T Instructional Technology Awards was last Friday. I drove back from Purdue in time to be there - mainly because I wanted to hear how people would respond to our faux radio interview 🙂 The event went off well, and people...

How does my browser know I am Indian?

Over the past few weeks I have noticed that some webpages I visit have banner ads that are targeted to me quite specifically - in particular to my Indian origin. For instance this page (a story about ipods being used by the army) contains a set of banner ads that seek...

Playing with light and shadows

Stumbled upon the creative work of Kumiya Mashita. It is amazing just how much can be created with just light and shadows. Just brilliant. Here are some examples:

26 years ago… My first publication!

Note: If you are not interested in the backstory but just want to read the story you can find a cleaned PDF version here. Mishra, P., & Narasimhan, A. (1987, August). And we all fall down. Science Today. Back in 1986, Anand Narasimhan and I wrote a short story...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *