Art, design & teaching great quote

by | Sunday, January 17, 2010

Steve Wagenseller, a student in my 817 Learning Technology by Design seminar wrote something so cool in the class forum that I felt that it was worth recording on my blog…

…One of the differences between art versus design is that a user has to approach the art, design has to approach the user.

Though, William James famously said, “Psychology is a science, teaching is an art,” (see the original quote in context here) I have always believed teaching to me closer to design and I think Steve captures in a very succinct way what the difference between art and design is – and why teaching is more design than art.

There is however, one aspect of the quote by James that is worth pointing out. Most people quote just the segment that I did, ignoring what he said right after that. The complete quote is as follows:

I say moreover that you make a great, a very great mistake, if you think that psychology, being the science of the mind’s laws, is something from which you can deduce definite programmes and schemes and methods of instruction for immediate schoolroom use. Psychology is a science, and teaching is an art; and sciences never generate arts directly out of themselves. An intermediary inventive mind must make the application, by using its originality. [emphasis mine]

Read the part in bold once again, “science never generate arts directly out of themselves. An intermediary inventive mind must make the application, by using its originality.” Even if we replace the word “arts” by “design” (as I have been arguing) the second part of the quote, the one emphasizing the importance of the “inventive mind” to develop “originality” still hold true. This creativity is essential to good teaching, and allows us to push beyond the science of psychology into the design of real learning experiences.


A few randomly selected blog posts…

Human-Centered values in a disruptive world

Human-Centered values in a disruptive world

I have seen the power of the market… But when it becomes the only language, when it becomes the only way of thinking about the right thing to do, it leaves us with a very impoverished sense of how to live together -- Giriharadas, 2018 Over the past few years I have...

Taare Zameen Par

Taare Zameen Par (loosely translated as "Stars on the earth") is a new movie produced and directed by Aamir Khan, one of Bollywood's biggest stars. He also acts in it. What is unique about this movie is that despite its Bollywood trappings, it is a somewhat serious...

Technology Integration in Higher Education

Matt Koehler and I led a session on Technology Integration in Higher Education: Challenges & Opportunities for a day-long symposium titled: Colloquium on the Changing Professoriate. This is how our session was described in the program book/website: Technology has...

Phoenix rising

Mark Ambinder at the Politics blog at the Atlantic President Obama plans to name Howard A. Schmidt, a veteran cyber security warrior with experience at senior levels of government and industry, to fill a long-anticipated cyber coordinator position at the National...

Jere Brophy, 1940 – 2009

There is a nice article in the State News about Jere Brophy including quotes from his daughter Cheri Spier, my department chair Dick Prawat, and my former advisee (now faculty member at Drexel) Aroutis Foster. Read MSU professor dies, honored by colleagues as field...

Control vs. Agency: Exploring the History of AI in Education

Control vs. Agency: Exploring the History of AI in Education

Over the past 12 years we have been writing a regular column in TechTrends, broadly around "Rethinking Creativity and Technology in Education." More recently, we have been exploring the complex relationship between emerging technologies and educational practices, with...

Best practice v.s. PGP

Best practice v.s. PGP

I was recently in a discussion with members of the AACTE committee on Innovation and Technology about the term "best practice." This search for best practice (or practices) is something one hears about all the time in educational (and ed tech) circles. We want to list...

The Absurd One-Sidedness of the Ethics of AI Debate: A  rant

The Absurd One-Sidedness of the Ethics of AI Debate: A rant

It seems no conversation about AI and education is complete without discussing the importance of the ethical use of the technology. There are numerous reports and academic articles about it (this and this and this ... I could go on and on). There is, however, one...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *