Mirror, mirror

by | Thursday, August 07, 2008

Imagine you are standing in front of a bathroom mirror; how big do you think the image of your face is on the surface? And what would happen to the size of that image if you were to step steadily backward, away from the glass?

A recent article in the NYTimes (Mirrors used to explore how the brain interprets information) has some interesting nuggets in it. The one that stood out was the rather straightforward one quoted above…

According to the researchers quoted in the article, most people answer the questions with some variation of the following:

To the first question they say, well, the outline of my face on the mirror would be pretty much the size of my face. As for the second question, that’s obvious: if I move away from the mirror, the size of my image will shrink with each step.

Turns out both of these typical answers are wrong!

I knew the answer to the first one – that the outline of my face in the mirror would be exactly half of the size of my real face. There are two main reasons for this. The first is the basic geometry of the fact that the mirror is exactly halfway between me and my image and second, that our brains over-compensate for size differences with distance (known as the size constancy effect). It is the combination of the two that (a) leads to the smaller, exactly half, size and (b) to our inability to realize that.

However, I had not truly understood the consequences of the geometry… So even though at some intellectual level I knew that that the image of my face would always be half its size in the mirror, I didn’t understand the consequence that it would always have to be that, irrespective of how far (or how close to the mirror I was). Wow… Turns out even things I thought I had understood, I didn’t fully understand!!

A good example of a véjà du moment!

You can find out more about size constancy by going here

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Math Concepts by Gaurav Bhatnagar

Gaurav Bhatnagar is one of my oldest friends - going back to 8th grade in Modern School, Barakhamba Road. He recently published his first book on Mathematics for kids, titled, Get Smart: Maths Concepts, published by Penguin India. The book also has an associated blog...

Educational Change by Design: A school for the future

Educational Change by Design: A school for the future

How do we design a school for the future? This recent article seeks to capture (in the form of a case study) our recent experience in designing such a school. The design process was a collaborative process involving a partnership with a local school district and the...

River run photos

Here are some photographs from the Capital City River Run half-marathon I completed this past Sunday (as reported here: Hurting but Happy). Here's one More here, here, here, here, here & here. Apologies for the copyright marks.

MSU Fight Song: MAET style

The summer of 2015, there were 133 students and instructors in the hybrid and overseas components of the MAET program. These people were spread out across three locations: East Lansing, MI (with 2 cohorts, Yr1 and 2 of MAET); Chicago, IL (with 2 cohorts of the...

Is TPACK fundamentally flawed? A quick response

Richard Olsen over in his blog has an extended posting titled The TPACK Framework is fundamentally flawed. It is a long and thoughtful post and I recommend everyone to read it. I have posted a short response to his posting (it is under moderation but should show up in...

Tipping point for online learning?

Tipping point for online learning?

Is the Covid19 crisis the tipping point for online learning? As we wrote in our introduction to the Silver Lining for Learning webinar series …this crisis has forced schools and universities to close, pushing often unprepared institutions to move teaching and learning...

Stuff Indian’s Like

After the success of Stuff white people like, can Stuff Indians like be far behind. Check it out... it has the occasional nugget that nails Indians and their behavior.

On making computation visible

Here is a cool video about a "a mechanical, binary adding machine that uses marbles to flip the bits" - in other words a computer made of wood, that works at a pace that we can grasp! Marvelous. (HT: Collision Detection). Check out the video: [youtube width="425"...

Daily routines of creative people

A while ago I had blogged about a webpage that chronicles how "artists work" (see my posting here). Now I discovered a whole website devoted to it. Check out Daily Routines. They are all interesting to read and the common theme that jumps out, for the most part, is...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *