Slipping into uncanny valley

by | Tuesday, May 06, 2008

MindHacks has a great post related to some of my previous postings about anthropomorphizing interactive artifacts (see here and here) – just that this time these artifacts under discussion are robots. As it turns out, sometime too much similarity between humans and robots can really mess things up in our mind – and we fall into, what has been called, uncanny valley.

A good example of uncanny valley is how strange and disturbing movies like Polar Express (that use sophisticated motion capture technologies) look like – mainly because they are close to human actions but not identical with them. Contrast that with how easily we can see personality and character in a set of dancing squiggles that make up cartoon movies. My favorite example of uncanny valley comes from Toy Story 2, where the toys look just perfect, when they move and speak. The illusion holds – and the characters come “alive,” in powerful, emotionally valid ways. However, the illusion collapses the moment they bring in a human (be it Andy or the “Chicken Man” or worst of all a little baby). Somehow our brains are unwilling to accept even minor lapses from full fidelity when it comes to humans.

For some reason, a mantra of computer graphic artists (whether they work in movies or in game design) is higher and higher fidelity. What is interesting is that by this they may actually be making things look less realistic.

In contrast, people see intentionality, agency and personality everywhere. This was demonstrated most cleverly by two psychologists Heider and Simmel back in 1949. They showed subjects simple film animations, mostly of geometric shapes, and asked them to describe what they saw. Most participants developed complex stories about these shapes, bringing in higher order constructs such as love and villainy to explain what they saw. If this seems really weird, take a look at one of these movies (here is a direct link to the movie, and a link to the page that describes this and other experiments). It is difficult not to see “narratives” in these rather abstract animations.

Anyway, the MindHacks post (Uncanny Valley of the Dolls, what a great title) provides links to online videos and research publications of Human-Computer Interaction researcher Karl MacDorman. This is a far cry from the little animate geometric shapes… and as fascinating.

In my 917 class, we spend quite some time discussing our relationship to artifacts. Interactive artifacts are interesting boundary objects that exist in between the artifactual and intentional worlds. It is no wonder our psychology gets all messed up when we have to interact with things like this. And these boundary objects are increasingly becoming part of the world we live in – whether they be robotic toys, or vacuum cleaners). As an educator, I often wonder how continuous interaction with such artifacts influences the way we think about artifacts, and about humans.

One of my research studies (with Andrea Francis) looked at how children respond to anthropomorphic toys.

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Digital footprint

My colleague Leigh Wolf shared with me an assignment completed by one of her students (Allison Keller) in a technology and leadership class she is currently teaching. How one person's use of technology has changed over time. [Hosted on Flickr] Click on the image to...

Teacher Knowledge in the age of ChatGPT and Generative AI

Teacher Knowledge in the age of ChatGPT and Generative AI

The rise of Generative AI (and tools such as ChatGPT) and their potential impact on education have been discussed and debated ad-nauseam. The key question, as teacher educators, is what it is that teachers need to know to intelligently integrate these technologies in...

TPACK Dissertation by Lisa Hervey

A couple of years ago I visited the Friday Institute at North Carolina State University. I had a wonderful time meeting old friends and making new ones. One of the old/new friends was doctoral student Lisa Hervey. As a part of her dissertation Lisa had been interested...

Indipix Gallery, cool photographs

The International Conference on Indian Education: The Positive Turmoil. is being held at the India Habitat Center in New Delhi. This Habitat center is a rather cool building and, apart from academic conferences (I saw two different conferences going on at the same...

TPACK Newsletters (#28, #29 & 30)

TPACK Newsletters (#28, #29 & 30)

In the rush of summer and the move to Arizona I missed posting #28 and #29 of the TPACK newsletter, and before I knew it, #30  was here as well. Well here are links to the PDFs of all three newsletters Newsletter 28: May 2016 (pdf)Newsletter 29: July 2016...

Gary Marks, Lifetime achievement award

Gary Marks is the director/founder of the Association for the Advancement of Computing in Education (AACE)and also the Executive Officer of the Society of Information Technology in Teacher Education (SITE). As a part of the 20th anniversary celebrations of SITE, Gary...

Students video premiere on aftered.tv

This just in. Leigh Wolf just informed me that a video created by three of her students this past summer accepted by AfterEd - a web-based video channel produced by EdLab at Teachers College, Columbia University. New content is published weekly, including news,...

It takes 10,000 hours

A quote in a NYTimes article caught my attention According to sports scientists, the most significant predictor of an athlete’s skill is the time spent in practice. “It’s not just genetics,” says Jean Côté, the director of the School of Kinesiology and Health Studies...

Poetry, Science & Math, OR why I love the web

A 5th grade science assignment, transformed. A rant about Mother Goose. A math poetry challenge!  How did that come to be? And what does that have to do with loving the Interwebs? Read on... I had written earlier about how my 10 year-old daughter had been writing...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *