Blast from the past: Technology, representation & cognition

by | Sunday, February 11, 2024

I published my first academic article (a book chapter) in 1996 when I was a PhD student at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign. My the advisor, Rand Spiro, had been invited to write a chapter for an edited book and asked me if I would be willing to join him and his colleague (Paul Feltovich) in writing it. I, of course, jumped at the opportunity.

Given that this paper was written almost 30 years ago it is amazing just how relevant some of the ideas explored in that paper are, even today. In fact I have found myself citing it and quoting from it quite a bit over the past year or so. To be fair, not all of the ideas we discussed in this paper have dated well, but I do find myself going back to the first half of the paper for inspiration and insight.

Sadly, however, given that it was a chapter in an academic book (and one I assume is now out of print) the chances of someone finding the paper is quite low. Moreover, I realized (to my surprise) that I had not shared the paper on my website, so this post is an attempt to redress this gap. A complete citation and link to a scanned PDF is given below:

Mishra, P., Spiro, R. J. & Feltovich, P. (1996) Technology, representation & cognition. In von Oostendorp, H. (Ed.) Cognitive aspects of electronic text processing. (pp. 287-306). Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.

The main argument made in the chapter (and the part that still holds relevance today) is that technologies have particular and specific attributes (often invisible to users of the technology) that prefigure or engender different mind-sets or ways of thinking. This question, of course, one that I have tried to grapple with in the new context we live in today—that of a world of generative AI. What IS the true nature of generative AI? What does that mean for us, as individuals and as a society? As I have argued, without understanding the true nature of this technology we will not be able to understand what it does for us, and as importantly, what it takes away.

I will be writing more about this in upcoming blog posts.

Topics related to this post: Publication

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Does the Internet mean that knowledge is obsolete?

I was recently interviewed by Wired magazine for a story about Sugata Mitra's (of Hole in the Wall fame) experiments with minimally invasive learning, or more recently what are called SOLE (Self Organized Learning Environment) classrooms / schools. I have been...

Principled Innovation meets Design: 1 new model and 2 videos

Principled Innovation meets Design: 1 new model and 2 videos

Our college has embraced the idea of Principled Innovation as being a core value that informs everything we do. (More on this in this post by Cristy Guleserian and in the PI framework document). Defining Principled Innovation: Design by Punya Mishra At the heart of...

New ambigram book, with 3 of my designs

Ambigrams Revealed: A Graphic Designer's Guide To Creating Typographic Art Using Optical Illusions, Symmetry, and Visual Perception is a new book edited by Nikita Prokhorov. The book showcases the works of ambigram artists from around the world. It includes...

Milap 2008

The Indian Cultural Society of greater Lansing (ICS) held its annual cultural program Milap 2008 this past Saturday. It was a great program with traditional and Bollywood dances, songs, and other performances. My daughter Shreya's dance troup, performed a Kathak dance...

Psychology and Coercive Interrogation, the history

In the context of my previous posting, here is an article that provides "a brief historical summary of the research into forms of coercive persuasion, primarily sensory deprivation, conducted 35 to 50 years ago, in which psychologists, psychoanalysts, and...

Being a tourist in Taipei

I woke up this morning, feeling maybe for the first time in this entire trip, tired and a little homesick. I ascribe the first to the rather hectic schedule I have had the past 10 days so, continually on the move, presentation after presentation, meeting after...

Meta poems too

Meta poems too

Layout is the first to go Lines of poetry are sacred to both the author and the reader. To alter the specific construction in line length is to alter the look and rhythm of the poem. However, as ebooks and eReading devices have become more prevalent, readers have come...

Self-similarity in math & ambigrams 3/3

Self-similarity in geometry is the idea of repeating a similar shape (often at a different scale) over and over again. In other words, a self-similar image contains copies of itself at smaller and smaller scales, such as the image below of the word "zoom."...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *