Ron Clark Academy, scalable?

by | Sunday, October 04, 2009

Scott McLeod over at Dangerously Irrelevant posted a video of a CNN story about the Ron Clark Academy and asked whether something like this was scalable?

Watch the video as you ponder this question.

This is a question often asked of me, when I am conducting creativity workshops or talking about passionate teaching. In fact I was asked this just a couple of days ago when I was at the Dexter Schools talking about 21st Century Learning and Creativity. This issues comes up most when I am in India where the magnitude of the problems is just so large that scalability is always an issue.

My response to this typically has been quite straightforward. I say that I can’t think that big. I have a congenital defect that renders me incapable of thinking of projects on a large scale. I cannot comprehend states and nations. I can barely comprehend a district. What I am most comfortable with is one classroom. What this does is color my way of thinking about innovation, pushing me towards the position that change can be effected one classroom at a time. When I teach my summer courses as a part of the MAET program, I usually have 25 students, a number I can comprehend. My goal is to touch these 25, to connect with them, and to raise within them a passion for using technology to teach subject matter. If I manage to touch even a fifth of them and they go back to their classes inspired to do something new and better, hey I have succeeded.

This is not to say that policies don’t matter that social change can’t happen. Just that I am personally incapable of thinking in grand generalities. I have a feeling that my skepticism regarding large scale efforts comes from my deep suspicion that visions and plans mutate in often detrimental ways when they move out of the local. So I stay in the local, and frankly that is good enough for me.

Now Scott may think that this is a cop-out and not necessarily a response to his question, but sadly that is the best I can give. The Ron Clark Academy works well where it does. Just training a bunch of teachers in the techniques used there and asking them to implement it in their classrooms will not necessarily translate into better student achievement. For instance, I am not sure that the Ron Clark approach would work in India, a country with very different cultural and historical expectations of what teaching and learning could/should be. So I choose to withhold judgment and work harder with the people I know I can influence.

Topics related to this post: Creativity | Engineering | Evolution | Learning | MAET | Teaching | Worth Reading

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Jeff Keltner from Google Education to talk today

There has been a great deal of interest in the educational use of cloud computing tools such as Google Docs in the College (and at MSU at large). Though these tools are often free and easy to use, they come with concerns about intellectual property and ownership of...

TPACK Handbook, Chapter 1

There have been many requests for the first chapter of the TPACK Handbook (recently published by AACTE & Routledge). Below is the summary and a link to the pre-publication version. Koehler, M.J., & Mishra, P. (2008). Introducing TPCK. AACTE Committee on...

The role of Vitamin D in beta-cell function

Who says scientists can't have fun. I just discovered a series of videos on (where else) YouTube about scientists expressing their doctoral research through dance!!! What can be cooler than that? Check out one of the winners: The role of Vitamin D in beta-cell...

KJZZ interview on STEAM education

KJZZ interview on STEAM education

I was interviewed recently by Mark Brodie of for a story titled: STEM Vs. STEAM: Educators Urge Adding The Arts To Classrooms. You can listen to the interview on their page by clicking on the link above, or the MP3 below. My piece comes in at around the 3:14...

TPACK Newsletter, #42 Nov. 2019

TPACK Newsletter, #42 Nov. 2019

Here is the latest pdf version of the TPACK Newsletter (#42, November 2019), as curated and shared by Judi Harris and her team. (Previous issues are archived here.) This issue includes titles, abstract and links to 116 articles, 5 book-chapters, and 34...

Post-lunch session: Nancy Law

The last session of the day was led by Dr. Nancy Law, Director, Centre for Information Technology in Education, University of Hong Kong. Her session was titled Using ICT to support learning: lessons learnt from international studies I met Dr. Law at SITE 2008 and then...

TPACK @ AERA, New York

In a few weeks TPACK will be going to AERA. There are a couple of events scheduled: First, is a symposium titled: Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPCK): A Conceptual Framework With Examples for Integrating Technologies Into Teacher Education [download...

India Week @ Erickson Hall

The Indian community in the greater Lansing area celebrates India Week every year (more or less) around March. [More details here and here.] As a part of this event I (and other members of the College of Education) have been organizing an Indian themed breakfast and...

TE150 presentation in streaming video

Terri Gustafson has created streaming downloads of the presentation recently made by the TE150 (Reflections on Teaching, Reflections on Learning) Online team (see this for more context). The video can be seen in two parts: Part I: The presentation "Reflections on...


  1. Graham Poole

    Many of my pals here and on the other board realize that my two children go to private school and realize that I am an advocate for good schools whether they are independent or public schools. The kids went to a great general public center college thankfully, so the transition to personal school isn’t as stark, but I must say private school has been a fantastic experience. Now I understand why the lucky preserve their great fortune – its extraordinary. Gettingadmitted to private school is no simple task though, and if you are serious about it you had much better be ready. You’ll need to take the ISEE test or the SecondarySchool Admission Test, and go through an interview with several members of the staff. I can tell you from expertise and from conversations with several other parents, this could be probably the most demanding period within your life. So you can imagine how difficult it is on the children, and if circumstances like this build character, they may have fantastic foundation.

  2. Kevin

    I really appreciate what Mr. Clark is trying to accomplish, the selling of books and movies, but to do it using kids and education is deplorable. I see that each child at his academy is equipped with a dell computer, free from a sponsor. If he can get that done is a place like Clayton County, where students are really in need, then I will be impressed. I am not impressed that he hand picks students for his school. I would really like to see the criteria used for picking these kids.

  3. Mr. Smith

    Ron Clark Academy loses 25% of the students that they handpick, if this was a public school we would scream for it to close. Their intentions are good enough but they never are recognized for their high student and staff turnover. Only one teacher, other than Ron Clark, is from the original staff and she is the co-founder.

    If someone was to truly look inside for the true facts they would see a very different story that the fable that has been told.

  4. Punya Mishra

    Thank you for your kind words. And, as to your whether students resist it – some do but again they usually have figured the system out well enough to know that this is just one more course with a faculty member setting weird goals and the trick is to do whatever is needed to get through the semester 🙂

  5. Cherice

    P.S. I would be curious to know what characteristics or criteria you use to discern/determine those who are most likely to be receptive to your influence?

  6. Cherice

    I am coming to believe that long-term change can ONLY be effected one student at a time, one teacher at a time, and therefore, one classroom at a time. That perspective has helped me to consider more carefully both the purposes of what I am teaching student teachers and the pedagogies I am using to do so. As a result, I have been working hard to reframe and refocus what I am doing in ways that keep the individual more clearly in view.

    With that said, one of the knotty problems I am currently wrestling with is how to support students in feeling comfortable experimenting with approaches that are so contrary to their prior experiences as learners and to their present images of teachers. Scaling that up to the mentor teachers who reinforce many of those prior experiences and conceptions of teaching/learning is an even more daunting task.

    My experiences in your class were quite antithetical to the rest of my schooling. Your approach gave me “vuja de experiences” that expanded the depth and breadth of my understanding, stimulated an appetite for further learning, and shifted my perspective in powerful ways. I’m wondering if you ever encounter students who resist that, and what approaches you take when they do?


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *