Clint Eastwood at war

by | Tuesday, March 11, 2008

I just finished watching Clint Eastwood’s two Iwo Jima movies: Flags of our Fathers and Letters from Iwo Jima. Clint Eastwood is an individual who I have come to respect a great deal. His evolution from the somewhat rabid “Make my day” vigilante to the nuanced and thoughtful filmmaker gives me hope (both for myself and for humanity). Ever since his directorial debut “Unforgiven,” Eastwood has developed into a tremendous director, willing to subvert genre cliches and deconstruct traditional tropes and narratives. These two movies are no exception.


Truth be told, I was somewhat underwhelmed by the first movie, Flags of our Fathers. It had a complicated narrative structure, multiple flashbacks within flashbacks and it seemed to me that the third section of the movie was weak and could have been deleted. As I was discussing with Matt (during the drive back from Detroit airport, coming back home from SITE), maybe American directors are not ready to truly tackle World War II. There is an obligation to pay respect to the Greatest Generation, and that can get in the way of filmmaking.

I was more impressed by the second movie. The two main characters, the general and the soldier, are both immensely touching characters. Personally, I have never understood war (and the war-like impulses of men) and the Japanese soldier captured my incomprehension quite perfectly. The section on the American POW seemed a bit tacked on, but otherwise this was a great movie. Most interesting, as Matt pointed out, were the scenes that overlapped between the two movies. This change in perspective, from American to Japanese, in these scenes, was fascinating to watch and think about. The flame-thrower in the first movie, setting a Japanese soldier on fire has a very different effect from one movie to the next and makes us question, quite subtly, the manner in which a movie’s narrative point of view seduces us to take a stand for or against a particular character (or set of characters).

Despite my criticisms, this is a wonderful pair of movies, made by a director fully in command of his medium (and the dollars in hand to realize his visions).

Topics related to this post: Film | Personal

A few randomly selected blog posts…

The Mirror Cracked: AI, Poetry, and the Illusion of Depth

The Mirror Cracked: AI, Poetry, and the Illusion of Depth

In a recent episode of Silver Lining for Learning on Hybrid Intelligence, I was going on about how AI systems are becoming increasingly sophisticated at mimicking human emotion and agency. Nothing new for readers of this blog - my usual concerns about synthetic...

Thoughtless acts? Technology, creativity & teaching

I have always been interested in the manner in which people use (or re-use) everyday things for purposes they were never intended for. Be it a piece of red tape to mark a glass door so that people don't slam into the glass (as I see at the MSU clinical center every...

Visually representing a song

How can anybody resist this flowchart / visual representation of Hey Jude! Check it out. Don't you just hear the song as you move through the boxes and arrows.

Designing learning in a transformed world: Keynote

Designing learning in a transformed world: Keynote

I was recently invited to present virtually at The Heart of Innovation Summer Summit, organized by the Heartland Area Education Agency in Iowa. The video of my talk can be seen below. Maybe my first serious keynote talk about generative AI and education. Enjoy...

Special CITE issue on TPACK

The CITE Journal had a recent special issue devoted to TPACK. You can access the special issue (edited by Judi Harris and Matt Koehler) here or individual articles below. Bull, G., & Bell, L. (2009). TPACK: A framework for the CITE Journal. Contemporary Issues in...

The intangibles of teaching

Jim Garrison and A. G. Rud have a wonderful article on TCRecord on Reverence in Classroom Teaching. Though, reverence may be "too exalted a word to associate with the practical and often mundane activities of teaching," it appears to me that ignoring these deeper...

Art is a lie… that tells the truth

Picasso famously said, "Art is a lie that tells the truth." This design below is my attempt to represent this quote - at least the first part of the quote. Of course, as most things go, it is not clear whether Picasso ever actually said these specific words. But...

Happy 2013!

Our family has a Christmas-break tradition. Over the past 5 years or so, every winter-break, we work together a create a video new-year's card. And of course, we made one this year as well. As you can imagine, coming up with original ideas has become increasingly...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *