Clint Eastwood at war

by | Tuesday, March 11, 2008

I just finished watching Clint Eastwood’s two Iwo Jima movies: Flags of our Fathers and Letters from Iwo Jima. Clint Eastwood is an individual who I have come to respect a great deal. His evolution from the somewhat rabid “Make my day” vigilante to the nuanced and thoughtful filmmaker gives me hope (both for myself and for humanity). Ever since his directorial debut “Unforgiven,” Eastwood has developed into a tremendous director, willing to subvert genre cliches and deconstruct traditional tropes and narratives. These two movies are no exception.


Truth be told, I was somewhat underwhelmed by the first movie, Flags of our Fathers. It had a complicated narrative structure, multiple flashbacks within flashbacks and it seemed to me that the third section of the movie was weak and could have been deleted. As I was discussing with Matt (during the drive back from Detroit airport, coming back home from SITE), maybe American directors are not ready to truly tackle World War II. There is an obligation to pay respect to the Greatest Generation, and that can get in the way of filmmaking.

I was more impressed by the second movie. The two main characters, the general and the soldier, are both immensely touching characters. Personally, I have never understood war (and the war-like impulses of men) and the Japanese soldier captured my incomprehension quite perfectly. The section on the American POW seemed a bit tacked on, but otherwise this was a great movie. Most interesting, as Matt pointed out, were the scenes that overlapped between the two movies. This change in perspective, from American to Japanese, in these scenes, was fascinating to watch and think about. The flame-thrower in the first movie, setting a Japanese soldier on fire has a very different effect from one movie to the next and makes us question, quite subtly, the manner in which a movie’s narrative point of view seduces us to take a stand for or against a particular character (or set of characters).

Despite my criticisms, this is a wonderful pair of movies, made by a director fully in command of his medium (and the dollars in hand to realize his visions).

Topics related to this post: Film | Personal

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Embodied Thinking: New article

Photo: Punya Mishra; Santiago, Chile, 2014 Rethinking Technology & Creativity in the 21st Century is a series of articles we have been writing for Tech Trends. The latest article in the series has just ben published. This article focuses on Embodied Thinking as a...

SITE 2008: A preview

Matt and I are at the SITE conference next week. He has blogged about it here... so I need to do my bit. We have a busy schedule at Las Vegas, which means less time for all the fun stuff. The big one is the Keynote by Matt and myself (more details below). Here is a...

OECD Global Forum on the Future of Education: Bucharest, Romania

OECD Global Forum on the Future of Education: Bucharest, Romania

I have been in Bucharest for the past few days participating in the OECD Global Forum on the Future of Education. It has been great fun, meeting lots of new people, developing frameworks around AI and education and more. A few resources and photographs from the...

Stuck with Google (recursively)

The other day, for one reason or another, I did a Google search for the word "recursion." According to Wikipedia, recursion ... in mathematics and computer science, is a method of defining functions in which the function being defined is applied within its own...

STEM teaching & leadership for urban educators

STEM teaching & leadership for urban educators

The MSUrbanSTEM project was one of the best projects I have ever been part of.  We worked with 124 Chicago Public School STEM educators over three years, in an effort to develop their teaching and leadership in the STEM areas. We have written about this...

iSad

Steve Jobs (1955 - 2011) To all of us who value creativity and design the passing of Steve Jobs is the passing of an era. I know my world changed when I first saw the Macintosh. I was a freshly minted electrical engineer who was trying to get out of engineering...

Emailing a plagiarist

I am sending the following email to David Jiles, Ph.D. whose plagiarism I have documented in this posting: David Jiles, Ph.D., Creativity Expert, Plagiarist. The email is as follows: Dear Dr. Jiles -- I have some questions and concerns about your book "Creativity and...

Art, design & teaching great quote

Steve Wagenseller, a student in my 817 Learning Technology by Design seminar wrote something so cool in the class forum that I felt that it was worth recording on my blog... ...One of the differences between art versus design is that a user has to approach the art,...

Creativity, genius & age

Malcolm Gladwell has a great essay in a recent New Yorker on the relationship between genius and age. It is popularly believed that genius is often tied up with precocity. There are two aspects to this. First, creativity requires the energy and brashness of youth....

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *