Remembering the original Influencers: JP, Jack, Nadu & Bandy

Part of: Teaching & Academic Life

Tagged: Ambigrams, Identity, Memory, Personal, Representation, Storytelling

One of the heartbreaking features of the past few years has been the passing of many people who have been my intellectual heroes. At some level this is to be expected but it hurts all the same. Over the past couple of years I have written a handful of posts remembering people who shaped my thinking and are no more: Lee Shulman, David Berliner, Bill Atkinson, John Langdon and Tom Stoppard. With most of them the connection ran through their work. I never met Atkinson, Langdon or Stoppard, and I met Lee Shulman only once, over dinner.

In some ways THIS post is overdue, since in this I pay my respects not to one person but to four: four individuals who were part of my life more directly, and have died in the last few months. J.P. Das, the Odia writer, sent me an email out of the blue almost twenty years ago and stayed in touch until the end. Jack Schwille was a senior colleague at Michigan State who backed my work in ways I never asked for. Sudhakar Nadkarni and Mohan Bhandari were my teachers at the Industrial Design Centre (IDC) at IIT Bombay. Professor Nadkarni died just a couple of days ago. Taking each of them in turn.

J.P. Das

J.P. Das died in Bhubaneswar on June 3 (my daughter’s birthday). He was 90. In Odisha he was known as one of the major figures of modern Odia literature, a poet, playwright and novelist who also wrote a book on the painters of Puri and a study of illustrated palm-leaf manuscripts. Before all that he had been a senior officer in the prestigious Indian Administrative Service, and as Collector of Kalahandi he ran famine relief during the drought of 1965–66. He took early retirement in 1984 to write full time. He received the Saraswati Samman in 2006, and in 1990 he declined the Sahitya Akademi Award. In keeping with his wishes there were no last rites, and his body was donated to AIIMS Bhubaneswar.

I came to know him because of an ambigram. As a graduate student at Illinois I had designed a reflection ambigram of the word “Oriya” (as the language was spelled in English then) and put it on a website along with my other designs. Sometime around 2007 J.P. Das was visiting Chicago, came across it, and wrote to tell me that he liked it and that he had caught the reference to the eyes of Jagannath. In our subsequent communication I learned that he knew my mother (herself an author), and my grandfather (a professor of linguistics), and that he had been in college with my father in the 1950s.

A few years later he wrote to me about something he had come across while reading a memoir by a retired civil servant. The memoir described someone who had tried to write his signature so that it could be read in both English and Hindi (that’s the ambigram connection again). As it turns out that budding bilingual ambigrammist was none other than Mahatma Gandhi. How crazy was that! When I asked JP if I could get a copy of Gandhi’s signature he took the time to go get it scanned and share it with me. (Incidentally, his email reached me on January 30, the anniversary of Gandhi’s assassination.) I wrote about all of this at the time, in a post on Gandhi, ambigrams and creativity.

To find out that Gandhi, THE Gandhi, had been spending time trying to think of writing his name bilingually was just amazing… (and finding) this connection between us touched me. Strongly.

Some years after that I visited JP at his apartment in Hauz Khas in Delhi. He was incredibly kind and gracious and for some reason our conversation turned to our shared interest in nonsense verse. When I left he gave me two of his nonsense-verse collections, Alimalika and Nanasense. Here was a man who had managed a district through a famine and written serious poetry and scholarship, and who also loved nonsense for its own sake, the play of sounds and the logic that are just silly and pointless.

We kept in touch off and on. He left Delhi and moved to Bhubaneswar. One day I got an email from him asking me to design an original ambigram. He had written a play, he told me, in which two characters read the same handwritten note differently, one as SORRY NEXT YEAR and the other as SONNY NASTY CAR, and he wanted to know whether I could turn it into an ambigram. He was 87, housebound, and still writing plays that turned on wordplay. We went back and forth over the next few weeks while I worked on the design.

I would try to meet up whenever I went to India but for one reason or another it never happened. And I regret that I didn’t try harder.

Screenshot

Jack Schwille

Jack Schwille died on September 21. He came to Michigan State in 1977 and stayed until he retired in 2013, and for about thirty of those years he led the College of Education’s international work. He worked on education projects in Guinea, Burundi, Tanzania, Egypt, China, Pakistan and Chile, and with Maria Teresa Tatto he co-directed TEDS-M, a seventeen-country study of how future mathematics teachers are prepared. The college has posted a fuller account of his career, as has the IEA.

I remember his continually pushing me to do something in the international education space, though that was not something that was part of my research agenda. He further supported internationalization efforts across the board and I know international students saw in him an advocate who they could reach out to at any time if they faced any challenges.

After I got tenure I told Jack that I wanted to do something in India around technology and learning. I did not have much more of a plan than that. Soon afterwards posters went up all over Erickson Hall with the cryptic title “Help Punya Find IT in India,” inviting faculty and students to come and hear what I had in mind and help me think it through. Jack had put them up. We had a full house. He went on to support my international work for years after that, particularly what we did with the Azim Premji Foundation and Azim Premji University.

Another memory is a smaller, but more profound, one. After a family trip to India we had shared photographs on Facebook. Jack, without saying anything to us, turned them into a printed photo book, paid for it himself, and mailed it to us. That gesture touched us deeply.

In a talk before he retired, Jack said, “Ultimately, what matters to me are people.” The last time I saw him was a couple of years ago, when we were visiting Michigan. At a time when the United States seems to be moving away from engaging with the world, someone like Jack stood out for his commitment to the idea of internationalization and serving as a model for all of us. He will be missed.

Sudhakar Nadkarni

Professor Sudhakar Nadkarni (Nadu to everyone) trained as a commercial artist at the J.J. School of Art in Bombay, studied industrial design at the Hochschule für Gestaltung in Ulm from 1962 to 1966, and in 1969 started the postgraduate design program at IIT Bombay that became IDC. It was the first program of its kind in India, and students spent most of their time doing design rather than sitting in lectures. He also started a business design program at the Welingkar Institute in Mumbai. Through all of it he kept up a design practice that ranged from everyday products to exhibitions, including Charles Correa’s Vistara exhibition on Indian architecture.

I have known him since I was a student at IDC, nearly forty years now. Two years ago I nominated him for a Padma award (you can see my letter of support here).

His laughter was infectious, and he met everyone the same way, whether they were students, staff, local craftspeople or famous designers visiting from abroad. In the nomination letter I wrote that from him I learned “to take the work extremely seriously, but not to take oneself too seriously,” and I still try to hold myself to that.

In many ways his character and world-view determined the culture of IDC. The informality, engaging with faculty on a first name basis, the weekend parties, and the commitment to work, to quality were all attributes Nadu brought to IDC. You can’t imagine what a breath of fresh air IDC was, in the late ’80s to all of us, steeped in the stultifying, hierarchical, regimented educational systems. This was IDC’s special sauce and a lot of it came from Nadu.

After IDC he moved to Assam to start the Department of Design at IIT Guwahati. As it happens, when he got to Assam he found bamboo everywhere, a material most designers at the time thought of as rustic and low-tech, and instead of bringing in what he already knew, he worked alongside local artisans and students to see what bamboo could do. That work led to school and hospital furniture that could be made, repaired and maintained locally. He was past sixty by then, the man who had founded IDC, and he started again as a learner.

When IIT Bombay gave me its Distinguished Alumni Award, I said in my acceptance speech that everything I had accomplished since, including that award, traced back to my years in the Master of Design program he had built. He never took himself too seriously, even in print. In a note for Mandar Rane’s book about his life, he wrote, “I am known as a forgetful teacher, father, friend and partner.”

Mohan Bhandari

Mohan Bhandari (Bandy as he was called) died earlier this year. He taught at the National Institute of Design in Ahmedabad before coming to IDC, where he taught courses in form and product design for many years.

He is the most complicated of the four for me to write about, because I have to be honest that we never really got along. I have sometimes wondered whether it was because I was seen as the “computer guy,” (not a true designer) but I do not know that, and some of this distance might have been caused by my blind-spots or biases. Even then I could see that he had a deep aesthetic sense, and I recognized it, but the two of us never truly aligned.

After he died, his former students began posting their memories of him, and I read them one after another. Many of them describe instructions that seemed cryptic at the time and made sense only once they had stopped to look and think. Many describe him as the teacher who changed how they saw, and how they worked as designers. One former student remembered meeting Bhandari again years later at IIT Bombay, when Bhandari asked him, “Why do you walk so fast?” He suggested that the student have his driver drop him at the gate and walk slowly to the building, leaving home behind before he started work, and then in the evening walk slowly back, leaving work behind before he went home.

I was always the person who walked too fast, and I still am. Reading that story, I wondered how much I had missed seeing because I was in such a hurry, at IDC and in all the years since. I had a chance to learn from one of the best teachers there and I did not take it. That is a humbling thing to realize, and it has made me think about how my own students see me, and what they might remember about me that I have no idea of.

*  *  *

Bhandari’s students showed me that a teacher keeps teaching after they are gone, through the stories their students remember and share. He has reached me that way, decades late, and it is part of why I wanted to write down my own stories of J.P. Das, Jack and Nadu now, while they are fresh.

I began this post with people whose work shaped me from a distance. These four shaped me up close, in ways large and small: a poet who, housebound at 87, wrote to ask me for an ambigram for his new play; a colleague who covered Erickson Hall with posters for an idea I had barely put into words; a founder who made IDC a place where students called their teachers by their first names; and a teacher whose questions his students are still repeating decades later.

These days “influencer” has come to mean someone with a large following and something to sell, which is a vapid use of a good word. JP, Jack, Nadu and Bandy were influencers in the original sense. None of them had a following of that kind, but each of them changed how the people around them saw and worked, mostly by example, and that is what it means to be an educator, whether or not one is a teacher by profession.