Beyond AI Slop: Pride, Joy & Creativity in a World Created by AI

by | Monday, December 01, 2025

Is generative AI killing creativity or helping us find new ways to be creative? In our latest AIR|GPT episode, we take on Charlie Warzel’s article: A tool that crushes creativity. He argues that generative AI is destroying creative work and polluting the digital world with “AI slop.” You can listen to the full episode by following the link below or on your favorite podcast app.

AIR | GPT: Beyond AI Slop: The Pride and Joy of Creativity Is Alive and Well, What’s Slowly Dying Is How We Define It

In our conversation, Caroline Kurban, Liz Kolb, Ruben Puentedura, Helen Crompton and I (under Errol St. Clair Smith’s smart guidance) explored how AI can both interrupt and inspire creativity. We also acknowledged the real challenges: students and teachers skipping the hard parts of creativity, the growing need for human connection, and the barriers to fostering original work. What may be slowly dying is not creativity itself, but the way we define it in the age of Gen AI.

One idea that emerged from Liz has stayed with me: the role of pride in creative work—the deep satisfaction that comes from making something yourself. This has sent me in some interesting new directions that I hope to explore in an upcoming post.


Below is a list of all the episodes of AIR | GPT

  1. The Creators of SAMR, TPACK, Triple E, SETI, and GenAI-U Launch New Podcast With a Review of NoteBook LM
  2. Para-social Relationships: The Pros and Cons of Falling in Love With Generative AI
  3. 2024 Mic Drop on the AIR GPT Podcast
  4. AI Schools Are Catching On: What They Get Wrong, What They Get Right, What They Are Teaching Us About Teaching
  5. Some Think More Deeply With Gen AI, Some Less: Here’s What’s Behind The Emerging Critical Thinking Divide
  6. The Science and Art of Teaching Creativity in the Age of Gen AI: What Every Educator Needs to Understand
  7. The Blindspots in AI Guardrails, Guidelines, and Good Intentions: What We Need, What We Don’t, and Why
  8. All Gen AI Studies Are Not Created Equal: What These Two Highly Cited Studies Overlooked, Why It Matters
  9. Grok This: When AI Goes Off the Rails, What Educators Need To Know About the Root Causes
  10. Three Years of Gen AI: The Lessons We’ve Learned, What We Plan to Do Differently As We Head Back to School
  11. Pedagogical Debt: What We Owe Our Students in an AI World
  12. Beyond AI Slop: The Pride and Joy of Creativity Is Alive and Well, What’s Slowly Dying Is How We Define It
Topics related to this post: Podcast

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Slumdog night (and Rahman)

Slumdog rolled into the Oscars tonight. More important to me were the two Oscars for A. R. Rahman for original score and song. It is time that the world recognized his genius. Here is a cartoon by Kaladhar Bapu from his site Point Blank A.R. Rahman by Kaladhar Bapu

India Breakfast, a photo report

The India themed breakfast at the College of Education, a kick-off for India Week, was a great success. [Here is a previous blog entry announcing this (and other) events.] I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the people who helped out, and also provide...

Center for American Progress Webinar: AI in Education

Center for American Progress Webinar: AI in Education

I had the pleasure, this morning, of participating in a panel discussion organized by the Center for American Progress, titled Leveraging Technology To Equip K-12 Students for Success. Although the title covered a broad view of technology, our focus was specifically...

Art, design & teaching great quote

Steve Wagenseller, a student in my 817 Learning Technology by Design seminar wrote something so cool in the class forum that I felt that it was worth recording on my blog... ...One of the differences between art versus design is that a user has to approach the art,...

ChatGPT as a blurry jpeg of the web

ChatGPT as a blurry jpeg of the web

Ted Chiang is one of the greatest, insightful writers working today. I had written previously about one his short stories in a post titled: Truth of fact and feeling: Unpacking McLuhan (2/3) about his short story The truth of fact and the truth of feeling. (If you...

(de)Signs, a series on Slate

Slate magazine is running an interesting series by Julia Turner on signs and their design. Two articles are now up The Secret Language of Signs: They're the most useful thing you pay no attention to. Start paying attention. Lost in Penn Station: Why are the signs at...

Making it in academia! Hmmm…?

Making it in academia! Hmmm…?

The question of impact of one's work is something that all researchers and scholars care about, particularly in applied fields like education. The question, however, is how is impact to be measured? Over the past few weeks I have had a few instances where my work has...

It takes 10,000 hours

A quote in a NYTimes article caught my attention According to sports scientists, the most significant predictor of an athlete’s skill is the time spent in practice. “It’s not just genetics,” says Jean Côté, the director of the School of Kinesiology and Health Studies...

Perceiving & Patterning as skills essential for creativity

We have been writing a series of articles for Tech Trends titled Rethinking Technology & Creativity in the 21st Century. You can see the full list here. One of the key focus areas of these articles is on what we call trans-disciplinary thinking i.e. a set of...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *