To thine own mind be true: Understanding cultural technologies, from cave walls to ChatGPT

by | Friday, November 15, 2024

For almost 12 years now we have been writing a column series for the journal TechTrends, exploring the intersection of technology, creativity, and learning. Recently, my colleagues and I have been diving deep into generative AI through conversations with scholars like Ethan Mollick and Chris Dede, discussions with school leaders, and analysis of social media conversations.

In this latest piece Nicole Oster, Danah Henriksen and I take a historical view of what we call “cultural technologies” – tools that fundamentally reshape how humans think, create, and communicate. Think of how writing allowed us to preserve knowledge across generations, or how television transformed public discourse into entertainment.

Drawing on thinkers like McLuhan and Postman, we explore how each new cultural technology, from cave paintings to ChatGPT, has profoundly influenced not just how we share information, but how we think and process knowledge. What makes generative AI unique is how it combines multiple characteristics of previous technologies – it’s interactive like social media, generative like writing, and adaptive like human conversation – while adding new capabilities we’re just beginning to understand.

Perhaps most importantly, we argue that navigating this new landscape requires more than just understanding the technology – it requires understanding ourselves. Our tendency to anthropomorphize AI, our cognitive biases, and our “Stone Age minds” all shape how we interact with these powerful new tools.

Complete citation and link to the article below:

Mishra, P., Oster, N., & Henriksen, D. (2024). To Thine Own Mind Be True: Understanding Cultural Technologies, From Cave Walls to ChatGPT. TechTrends. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11528-024-01011-7

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Transplanted Man

I just finished reading Transplanted Man by Sanjay Nigam. A strange but entirely fascinating and satisfying novel with quirky and interesting characters. Nigam is quite willing to tackle difficult and "big" questions but does it with a light touch. I had read his...

SITE 2010, symposium on TPACK

I just got back from an extended trip to California (San Jose and San Diego). I will be posting a lot more about this trip but for now here are the slides from a symposium on "Strategies for teacher professional development of TPACK" organized by Joke Voogt of Twente...

Hello Taiwan

Arrived at Taipei airport and got through immigration and customs quite quickly. I was received at the airport by Waiway Lin, a doctoral student at the Graduate School of Curriculum and Instruction at the National Taipei University of Education. It appears that she...

Mind(ful) Wandering & Creativity: New article

Mind(ful) Wandering & Creativity: New article

Illustration by Punya Mishra We have covered a wide range of issues related to creativity, technology and learning in our almost decade-long series that we write for the journal TechTrends. Over the past few years we have conducted almost 30+ interviews with some of...

TPACK in Science Ed (Video)

Jamie Smith at Ohio University has created a Prezi presentation on TPACK in Science Education. I think it is a pretty good introduction to the topic. Enjoy

The Hidden Metal in Ghalib’s Heart

The Hidden Metal in Ghalib’s Heart

Mirza Ghalib, was a celebrated poet who lived in Delhi in the 19th century Delhi. He was as famous for his wit and defiance of conventions as he was for his verses. He mostly wrote ghazals—a form of lyric poetry built of rhyming couplets, each standing alone yet...

Ed Psych in a digitally networked world

Figure/Ground ambigram for Educational Psychology by Punya Mishra It has been a while coming, but finally the 3rd Edition of the Handbook of Educational Psychology is finally here. We have a chapter in it about the manner in which digital and networking technologies...

Of ballots and names…

Jon Krosnick, a professor at Stanford, argues that Hillary Clinton's surprise victory in the New Hampshire primary (contrary to what was being predicted in the pre-election surveys) could be simply due to the design of the ballot! Here is is the key quote: Our...

Finding In/Sight: A Recursive Dance with AI

Finding In/Sight: A Recursive Dance with AI

In this post, I share a conversation with Claude.AI (my words in purple, Claude's in blue) that began as a playful exploration of visual wordplay. What emerged was something unexpected - not about AI's lack of consciousness, which was never in doubt, but about the...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *