RickRolled by AI

by | Monday, May 29, 2023

ChatGPT does not cease to surprise.

As I had described in my previous post (Plugin’ into superpowers), I have been playing with some of the plugins that are now available to use with ChatGPT4, In this post I describe my experience in playing with a plugin titled Video Insights. Video Insights is described as a plugin that allows you to “Interact with online video platforms like Youtube or Daily Motion.”

To test out this plugin I shared a link to a YouTube video of a talk I had given, recently, at Brigham Young University. With just the YouTube address, and no prompting on my part, ChatGPT4 (with the help of the plugin) began giving me an abstract of the talk.

As it happens, the first summary it generated was completely and utterly wrong. Hallucination of the highest order. It performed much better when I asked to regenerate. The second time around, it came up with a pretty good description / summary of the video (that I am linking to here).

I then asked it to create a transcript of the video. This is of interest to me, since I would love to get better and cleaner transcripts of YouTube videos (particularly for the videos we create for the Silver Lining for Learning webinar/podcast). Once again the first couple of responses were clearly hallucinatory in nature – and not connected, in any way, to the video that it had been linked to. Over and over, just spewing a completely random sentences that were completely unrelated to the video I had shared.

So, instead of trying to get it to regenerate one more time, I explicitly told it that what it was typing was NOT related to the talk in the video.

It is here that things took a totally unexpected turn. Below is a transcript of that part of the conversation.

Me: This is not Punya’s talk

Chat GPT: Used Video Insights


I apologize for the confusion, but it seems there was a mix-up with the video IDs. The transcript you received is for the music video “Never Gonna Give You Up” by Rick Astley, not Punya Mishra’s talk. Let’s try again to get the correct transcript.


Please provide the correct YouTube link for Punya Mishra’s talk.

WT*. Did I just get RickRolled by ChatGPT!

How crazy is that!

A bit of research revealed to me what was really going on.

For the record, here is a screenshot of the conversation, just in case you think I was just hallucinating!

Postscript: I am not sure this plugin is all that interesting or useful. I think it is working from the close-captioning transcript auto-generated by YouTube, not the video itself, which is why it can come up with an abstract/summary (since it is essentially working with text) but fails miserably when asked to create a transcript from the actual video.

Topics related to this post: AI | Creativity | Fun | Personal | Puzzles | Stories | Technology | Worth Reading

A few randomly selected blog posts…

TPACK & Creativity at Cedar Rapids

I had a wonderful day at the Grant Woods Area Education Agency at Cedar Rapids, Iowa. I was invited there by Andy Crozier and his team as a part of their 21st Century Learning Institute. I spent the day with 50+ teachers, library media specialists, and administrators...

Solzhenitsyn, RIP

Every now and then it happens. The state or the system encounters an individual who, bafflingly, maddeningly, absurdly, cannot be broken -- Christopher Hitchens Alexander Solzhenitsyn is no more. He was not an easy author to read - and the last time I read him was...

Inside-Out: Happy 2015

Every winter break (for the past six years) our family creates a video to welcome the new year. This is no ordinary video. It requires days of discussion, planning, construction, shooting, and editing. Our videos never feature us (expect maybe a still-shot of the...

Algorithms, Imagination & Creativity

Algorithms, Imagination & Creativity

Is music a craftOr is it an art?Does it come from mere trainingor spring form the heart?Did the études of Chopinreveal his soul's mood?Or was Frédéric ChopinJust some slick "pattern dude"?~ Douglas Hofstadter Ed Finn is the founding director of the Center for Science...

New edited series on Research to Practice

A few months ago I was invited (by the Educational Technology & Management Academy, an Indian educational organization) to write a series of short practitioner-oriented articles for a new educational e-magazine they were starting. The idea was to introduce to a...

Ads in Video Games

A couple of people have emailed me about the Obama campaign inserting advertisements into video games. Check out this Flickr set with screenshots of these advertisements. Most of the press is reporting that these ads show up in just racing games but as these...

Student engagement, a response to @ewilliams65

In a couple of previous blog post (Student engagement in school, the tale of 2 graphs and Understanding student engagement) I wrote about  the findings of a recent Gallup Poll on student engagement. The first post was concerned with how the data were represented and...

Designing 917: A conversation

Danah Henriksen and I taught CEP917 (Knowledge Media Design) last semester. This was a somewhat unique class, with half the students being present here on campus and the other half online. We met synchronously once every two weeks and the rest of the class happened...

The futures of higher ed with Phoebe Wagner

The futures of higher ed with Phoebe Wagner

The Center for Science and the Imagination at ASU runs a series of short stories and virtual gatherings that explore issues related to transformative change. Essentially they solicit and publish a (super-short) short story that explores “themes of community,...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *