Looking for design in Barcelona

by | Thursday, February 02, 2012

Readers of this blog know that I am always looking for examples of good / bad design (actually I am usually not looking for bad design – it just sort of comes and slaps me on the side of the head!). I thought I might share one with you today, that I found in my hotel room in Barcelona. First off here is  what it looks like.

Rather cool don’t you think? Well, as always, there is more…

However, as I began to use it, I found it frustrating and difficult for a range of reasons.

First, it was hard to put the phone back on the stand in the dark – the cool “perch” required precise placement – not something you can do easily while barely awake.

Second, the buttons (apart from the numbers for dialing) had these cryptic icons that made no sense. This of course meant that the hotel had to provide a “manual” to “teach” us how to use the phone (and you know, from a previous posting, what I think of user-manuals).

And finally, the numbers to make obvious phone calls (front desk, manager etc.) were quite non-obvious. Why ask guests to dial 31 or 32 to reach the front desk? Why not just “1” for the front desk (just as they had “0” for dialing out). And what is the distinction between 31-32 and 41/42? Does the hyphen mean something different from the slash? How many digits are there between 31 and 32 anyway to deserve a hyphen?

Final verdict on the phone, nice piece of visual design – no so much from a user-interface perspective. As they say, good from far and far from good!

Topics related to this post: Uncategorized

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Education by Design, 1 year progress report

Education by Design, 1 year progress report

"Time" 180-degree rotationalchain ambigram © Punya Mishra I have been at the Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College for two years now (actually two years and a month, but who is counting). In many ways this has been an incredible two years, a period of personal and...

David Jiles, Ph.D., Creativity Expert, Plagiarist!

I do not know who David Jiles, Ph.D. is. I do know that he is a plagiarist, an intellectual crook and a thief of the highest order! I do not write these words lightly. I was first informed of this by Mike Deschryver and have over the past few days attempted to look...

The incredible drowning man (returns)

It's good to be back at Twente, meeting old friends and making some new ones. I had a pretty light day yesterday, which was good because I had gone around 30 hours without any sleep. After checking into the hotel and getting a short but much needed nap, I took a walk...

Hobnob with MSU faculty

Paul Morsink & Bakar Razali, two graduate students in our college have been doing this interesting variant of the 60 second lecture. They record short videos of individual faculty members talking about anything that interests them and through that allow viewers to...

From being to becoming: Keynote by Shawn Loescher

From being to becoming: Keynote by Shawn Loescher

It is rarely that I hear a talk that blows me away. We have all seen the TED talks, and their mutant offspring. The over-hyped music and catchy taglines; the speaker in front of a rapt audience; the crafted delivery with its carefully punctuated pauses and reveals,...

4 AM: A poem

4 AM: A poem

4 AMJuly 17, 2019 The stupid smoke detectorsBeep IncessantlyThere are two of themRunning this conversationWith each otherThrough the night Their batteries dyingOr dead Funnily enoughThey fall silent during The dayLull you into thinking It is okIt was just a glitch But...

TPACK & Creativity at Cedar Rapids

I had a wonderful day at the Grant Woods Area Education Agency at Cedar Rapids, Iowa. I was invited there by Andy Crozier and his team as a part of their 21st Century Learning Institute. I spent the day with 50+ teachers, library media specialists, and administrators...

TPACK Newsletter, Issue #16, May 2013

  TPACK Newsletter, Issue #16: May 2013 Welcome to the sixteenth edition of the (approximately quarterly) TPACK Newsletter! TPACK work is continuing worldwide. This document contains recent updates to that work that we hope will be interesting and useful to you,...

Quick Design Video: Are you ready for the future?

Leigh Wolf and Ken Dirkin, instructors in the year III of the MAET program in Plymouth have been assigning, what they call, Quick Design assignments. These are quickfire challenges for students to showcase their talents under pretty severe constraints (of time,...

3 Comments

  1. Nick W

    Oh wow, that really is quite a bad design. Maybe they actually did not want anyone to use the phone.

    Reply
  2. Randall@ipad apps development

    Nice example of the situation when design prevails convenience. But in my view a regular hotel room is not a proper place for such showpieces.

    Reply
  3. Paula

    The visual design is also far from good I think

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *