Exploring visual space with mathematics

by | Thursday, April 30, 2009

Stacy Clause just sent me this very cool link to an article titled Exploring logo designs with Mathematica. In this article, Chris Carlson, of the User Design Group at Mathematia shows how one can mathematically develop variations on commercial logo designs by the systematic tweaking of various parameters. As Chris says,

As starting points for design explorations, corporate logos are ideal. They often distill a single idea into simplified geometric form that is straightforward to parameterize in Mathematica. Once a logo is in Mathematica, exploring its parameter space quickly leads to the discovery of new graphic phenomena, emergent forms, unexpected relationships, and burgeoning lines of inquiry.

What does this mean for graphic design (and graphic designers)? Does it mean that computers can now do what we used to pay people to do? This could be grim news for designers, particularly when they are already under siege from democratizing Web 2.0 tools like CrowdSpring (whose tag line is “just post your project, watch the world submit ideas and choose the one you like”). Below are some of my thoughts on this issue.

Coming back to Carlson’s work. Go ahead and read the entire article but I would like to highlight one of his examples to make my point. For instance consider the Mercedes-Benz logo

Carlson takes this and writes some Mathematica code to re-create the logo “with some obvious parameters controlling the number of points on the star, the sharpness of the star’s points, the thickness of the outer circle, and the orientation of the star.” And then it is just a question of tweaking the parameters… And look at some of the variations he has come up with!

One could respond to this by thinking that technologies like this mean that the creative, human element has somehow disappeared! That creativity can now be programmed. What are graphic designers to do? Are they now out of jobs? Is the computer going to do everything and thus replace the graphic designer?

I am not sure that is the case. There are two important issues here that we need to think about. First, this is a great way to automatically create variations on a theme – which I have argued is the crux of creativity. However, this does not mean that humans are out of the picture totally. In fact the human steps in at two crucial points in this process.

The first is in choosing which parameters to include in writing the original code. That is not totally obvious and needs careful thought. Should you include the thickness of the outer circle? What about color? The options are large and the choices non-obvious. Setting and tweaking different parameters will lead to very different solutions.

The second place where humans step in is after all these variations have been created (and the computer creates LOTS of them). Selecting one for its appropriateness to organization for whom the logo is being designed, finding the right aesthetic look, understanding the context of use (on a website, on a car dashboard, in neon?)… all of these need human insight.

I do not mean to argue nothing will change for designers. Not at all. These new tools do have implications for how designers work, and of particular interest to me, since I am an educator, is how we train the next generation of designers. Clearly taking advantage of these new tools needs a new set of skills. For instance, programming is not something we typically teach in design school. In fact, artists and designers are often (and pardon me for stereotyping) trying to move away from mathematics. But as is clear, a designer with a good visual sense AND a knowledge of programming and mathematics is going to be much more efficient and generative (in terms of total ideas) than one with just the former.

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Ganapati 08, Photos

As un-official photographer for the Marathi Group, I took a bunch of pictures of this year's Ganapati celebrations. These are now (finally) on Flickr. Enjoy.

TPACK commercial, UPS/Whiteboard version

Our ISTE Radio/Video show needed a few commercials to break the monotony - so we created a couple. Here is the first one, a take on the UPS / Whiteboard commercials. Watch and enjoy (director's commentary provided below)....

Trans-disciplinary creativity takes root (slowly)

I wanted to bring attention to two articles that came across my desk today. The first was in the Chronicle of Higher Education titled Creativity: a Cure for the Common Curriculum on efforts at range of universities seeking "to train students in how innovative thinkers...

Help me, find a story by Ursula Le Guin

Help me, find a story by Ursula Le Guin

 I am looking for a short story by Ursula Le Guin that I read many years ago growing up in India. The story has stayed with me but I cannot find it, despite many deep dives into the internet. I have posted on reddit, on the Ursula Le...

The School Design Game v 1.0

The School Design Game v 1.0

The journey  of design is complicated, filled with conundrums —some expected, others not so much. There are many possible strategies  to address them as we iterate our way to the finish line. The School Design Game seeks to explore some of these complexities...

Rethinking Creativity, Race, Culture & Education

Rethinking Creativity, Race, Culture & Education

Episode 115 (dated July 30, 2022) of the Silver Lining for Learning webinar series focused on critiquing existing research on creativity - which for the most part has focused on the psychological and cognitive aspects of creativity. The guests on the show (Lori Patton...

Cognitive psychology of science: Old article

Cognitive psychology of science: Old article

Science ambigram with 180-degree rotational symmetry This chapter, published back in 1998, focused on the cognitive science of science. I realized today that I had not uploaded this article onto my website. So, better late than never, here it is. But before jumping...

Dreams of our futures

I started this blog on the 1st of January 2008. Barely 4 days later I a posted a video and asked the question, Is this a defining moment of our time? See it here Almost exactly six months later my question was partially answered, and I blogged about it here. Today,...


  1. Randal Ebsen


    Fun article. Simply wanted to let you know. Design & inspiration always together.

  2. Stace

    Certainly an interesting take on the Mathematica site. I find Mathematica quite the reverse- that is, designs can be expressed mathematically. Given that we may only see one or two iterations of a design, its quite interesting to visualize how tweaking a function (visually)produces different patterns ( ” what happens if…”).

    I think we are starting here on different levels of expertise; Mathematica (and I recommend the site for statistical visualizations as well) as a marriage of both art, design, and math has given me much to think about in terms of how relationships are expressed in different modes, whether algebraic or visual. Imagining statistics or mathematical functions when analyzing a study ( i.e. where does the p value lie in relation to degrees of freedom, what does regression look like) seem much like the changes in the designs above and do much to improve my understanding of any design- logo or research.



  1. Creativity, computers & the human soul | Punya Mishra's Web - [...] towards computers becoming partners in the creative activity itself. For instance read this post Exploring visual space with mathematics…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *