The more things change…

by | Sunday, January 25, 2009

I had posted earlier about a recent commercial that, though arguing at one level that technology can fundamentally change education, seemed to stick to the standard-lecture (albeit in different and cooler modes of transmission).

Just how little the discourse around educational technology has changed over time (while the technologies have changed drastically) was brought home to me recently through a book I borrowed by Patrick Dickson. Before I describe the book let me provide you one quote from that book.

The scope and nature of man’s learning have always been commissioned by the mediums of instruction which were available. The need for adapting himself to the changing conditions of his environment focused man’s attention upon bettering the tools by which he acquired learning…The modern school is forced to meet the demands of a rapidly changing civilization. Today the world of the learner is almost unbounded. He must acquire facts relating to a bewildering variety of places and things; he must acquire appreciations of far-reaching interrelationships. The curriculum and methods of teaching must undergo a continuous appraisal. New subject matter and new devices for instruction are being scrutinized for their potential contributions to the learning process.

Now this quote above could have come from any recent book on Educational Technology. In actuality, it comes from a 1933 book on using moving pictures in the classroom! The full citation is as follows:

Devereux, F.L. (1933). The educational talking picture. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
The entire text can be accessed online here.

The technology they are talking about is the latest technological breakthrough of their time, namely Educational Talking Pictures. What is amazing is that though technologies changes so drastically, (imagine Educational talking pictures v.s. YouTube) the discourse hasn’t changed one bit.

Here are some more quotes (thanks to Kristen Kereluik for typing these out). I have replaced contemporary technologies for some of the older ones (with the older technologies in square parenthesis). See how they read.

The contribution of the Internet [sound picture] to education depends upon its effective utilization quite as much as upon the manner in which it is produced. The teacher who uses the Internet [shows a sound picture] simply to maintain the interest of his students, and who lets the matter rest with the projection, overlooks the values which accrue when the technology [film] functions in a unit of activity.

The proper kind of technology [sound-film] presentation opens up challenging roads to further learning; it generates an urge to acquire new understandings and new appreciations.

Technology [The educational talking picture] can achieve these potential contributions only when based upon adequate curriculum research. It must follow those principles of teaching method which are peculiarly appropriate to the medium, and it must employ the technical devices which will best embody these principles.

The Internet [educational talking picture] is not just a teaching device that might be compared with a piece of apparatus in the laboratory, the building blocks of the kindergarten, or the blackboards and other equipment of the classroom. The introduction of the use of the Internet [talking picture] into education may prove to be an event as epochal as the application of the principle of the wheel to transportation or the application of steam power to the industrial age. No development in education since the coming of the textbook as held such tremendous possibilities for increasing the effectiveness of teaching as the Internet [educational talking pictures]….An important advantage in the use of the Internet [talking pictures] in the educational program is the extent to which they unify subject matter.

Teachers must acquire a thorough understanding of this new medium of instruction, including the correct utilization techniques…Probably the most complex problem in connection with the use of any mechanical aid to instruction is the integration of the use of the aid with teaching method and the curriculum.

What all these quotes tell me is that we need a new discourse, a new way of talking about the relationship of technology to teaching, particularly the role of research in helping identify effective pedagogical techniques, and the creative, designerly role of the teacher. The TPACK framework is one part of the argument – but its extensions into teacher creativity, something that is increasingly becoming part of my thinking about this, is another.

Matt Koehler, Kristen Kereluik and I are working on some papers on these issues, so I am being brief here, but I can point to a previous blog post that may be worth reading.

Topics related to this post: Creativity | Design | Evolution | Film | Learning | Research | Teaching | Technology | TPACK | Worth Reading

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Making it in academia! Hmmm…?

Making it in academia! Hmmm…?

The question of impact of one's work is something that all researchers and scholars care about, particularly in applied fields like education. The question, however, is how is impact to be measured? Over the past few weeks I have had a few instances where my work has...

Links of interest

During Dr. Jalaluddin's keynote I took some time to search online for some reports, prompted by what he had been saying. (Yes I was listening not just browsing). The first is an European study: ICT in Schools: Trends, Innovations and Issues in 2006-2007. You can...

Goodbye 2016, Welcome 2017

Goodbye 2016, Welcome 2017

Since 2009, our family has made short videos to welcome the new year. These videos are great fun to create, often requiring days of discussion, planning, construction, shooting and editing. They are always typographical in nature, often with a visual twist...

EPET at SITE, 2014

SITE2014 (the annual conference of the Society of Information Technology in Teacher Education) is being held in Jacksonville, Florida starting the 17th of March. As always, the Educational Psychology and Educational Technology program at MSU has a significant presence...

Unpacking Design & Creativity @ Purdue

The presentation Unpacking Design and creativity: What I think I know, and what I (quite certainly) don't is done, and it went well (I think). You can read the abstract here or view the presentation below Or see it full screen, by clicking here. After the presentation...

Fear, awe and the algebra of the pendulum

In response to my previous posting titled How artists work, Leigh Wolf pointed out a book (Curious Minds: How a child becomes a scientist). I had not heard of this book before and a quick google search led me to this page. Edited by John Brockman (the brains behind...

Bollywood meets Guitar Hero

Over the Christmas break my daughter and three of her friends got together to make a music video. The idea was simple, what if there were a version of Guita Hero (Sitar Hero anyone?) for Bollywood songs. Out of this idea emerged a 5+ minute long music video - with a...

Poetry, Science & Math, OR why I love the web

A 5th grade science assignment, transformed. A rant about Mother Goose. A math poetry challenge!  How did that come to be? And what does that have to do with loving the Interwebs? Read on... I had written earlier about how my 10 year-old daughter had been writing...

ChatGPT for Teachers: Insights from Online Discussions

ChatGPT for Teachers: Insights from Online Discussions

In our ongoing exploration of creativity, learning, and technology for the journal TechTrends, my co-authors and I have turned our attention to the fascinating intersection of generative AI and education. Our past interviews have featured innovators such as Chris...

0 Comments

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Here we go again, the recurring cycle of hype and despair around ed tech – Punya Mishra's Web - […] see how this has played out over and over again please see my post titled “The more things change…”…
  2. A TPACK video mashup! | nashworld - [...] We need to approach this with some humility since technologies have often been hyped as leading to fundamental educational…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *