Who is god rooting for?

by | Sunday, October 12, 2008

I have often wondered, while watching sports movies, particularly the ritual prayer scene before the big game, as to who is god rooting for? I mean, surely the other team is invoking god as well? So how does god decide? And if one team wins does that mean their god is stronger or their faith more deeply held?

I was reminded of all this by reading online that a pastor at a recent McCain rally said the following (see this for a report AND an mp3 version)

I also would also pray, Lord, that your reputation is involved in all that happens between now and November, because there are millions of people around this world praying to their god–whether it’s Hindu, Buddha, Allah–that his opponent wins, for a variety of reasons. And Lord, I pray that you will guard your own reputation, because they’re going to think that their God is bigger than you, if that happens. So I pray that you will step forward and honor your own name with all that happens between now and election day.

This just seems silly and mis-conceived at multiple levels.

Well, first of all there are those of use who are not praying – ‘cos they don’t pray – but still hoping for a Obama victory (which I guess means a McCain loss). I have not hidden my opinions about this election and my preference for how I would like this election to end-up, but I don’t pray for it. I wish this person had mentioned that some non-believers are also hoping for McCain’s loss. I am also sure that some non-believers are hoping that he win, as well. The point being that I am bit miffed that, once again, people of no belief have been ignored! Darn it 🙂

Second, the pastor makes a huge category mistake — lumping together a religion with the gods of other religions. Buddha is a god (at least for some Buddhists) and Allah is a god, but Hindu is surely NOT a god. A Hindu is a follower of Hinduism. As it turns out a Hindu can believe in everything, from the statement that there is no god to the mind-boggling idea that there are 320 million gods! (In that sense I understand the dear pastor not wanting to list all of them). But his category mistake needs to be pointed out.

Third, and more importantly, I think the pastor makes a huge mistake by asking his god to “guard” his reputation because a McCain loss would mean that “they” (always beware of “them”) are going to make the assumption that “their God is bigger than you.” Now what if McCain does actually lose.. what is this poor pastor to do? Does the Dalai Lama issue a statement that Buddha now rules!

Fourth, and just in case someone thinks that I am blaming just the McCain camp, though I do have differences with some recent events in their campaign, I must point out my similar reactions to the Obama rally I recently visited. Obama’s speech was preceded by a speech by a pastor (whose name I did not record) who made a similar religious argument about how god supports change. I wish I hadn’t been there to listen to that drivel.

Like I said, I wonder who god is rooting for?

Topics related to this post: India | Personal | Politics | Religion | Worth Reading

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Of garbage cans and psychological media

This has been a day of sad news from Stanford University. I blogged about the passing away of Dr. Nalini Ambady (see blog post here). I will digress a bit before I describe the second piece of news because the connection to me (and my work) is much more salient. Back...

Ask-ing Cuil questions of Google

How do we evaluate a search engine? Chris Wilson attempts to answer this question (with help from the crowd) in his article on Slate "How To Talk to a Search Engine: Three queries to help decide if Google or Cuil or Ask is right for you?" The three search items he...

The value of school: Part 1

The value of school: Part 1

Note: This is the first of two posts on the value of school by Punya Mishra & Kevin Close. Read the second post: Revisiting Accountability. What value do schools bring? The accepted assumption is that schools are sites for learning and the role of educators to...

When tech comes first: The Khan Academy as leading pedagogical change

As I go around the country talking about the TPACK framework, one of the questions that is always put to me is, about which comes first when planning a lesson, content, pedagogy or technology. The standard answer is that content comes first since it is only after we...

India Week @ Erickson Hall

The Indian community in the greater Lansing area celebrates India Week every year (more or less) around March. [More details here and here.] As a part of this event I (and other members of the College of Education) have been organizing an Indian themed breakfast and...

Mishra, Nicholson & Wojcikiewicz (2001/2003)

Mishra, P., Nicholson, M., & Wojcikiewicz, S. (2001/2003). Does my wordprocessor have a personality? Topffer’s Law and Educational Technology. Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy. 44 (7), 634-641. Reprinted in B. C. Bruce (Ed.). Literacy in the information...

David Jiles plagiarism issue, update

An update on the ongoing saga of David Jiles, Ph.D. For context see this. (Please note the David Jiles referred to in these posts is NOT Professor David Jiles of Iowa State University and Cardiff University.)  I have heard back from some of the websites that had...

1 Comment

  1. Vijay Kumar

    God Almighty is not form of human beings. God Almighty always acts as a Dhrishta (onlooker) never interfering with creation of his! God Almighty is Nirakaar in form (having no form)! Ever since creation of cosmos whole cosmic system is governed by irrefutable laws of karma…. as we sow so shall we reap… nothing less or more!

    Human form is highest manifest stage in cosmic life cycle. Only in human form our soul atman finally regains its lost original pure prime pristine primordial form when human beings reached stage of enlightenment (kaivalya jnana)! The destiny of mankind is governed by our karma! As we perform… accordingly manifests our destiny!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *