Spore & learning about evolution

by | Friday, September 05, 2008

A NYTimes story about Spore, the new game / toy designed by Will Wright (Playing God, the Home Game) speaks about its connection to evolution. As the article says,

Mr. Wright and his publishers at Electronic Arts deserve all the credit they have received from some scientists merely for making a game about evolution (though it will be fascinating to see how the game fares among people who do not believe evolution is real).

This raises the interesting question as to whether this game can be used to actually teach evolutionary theory.

However, I am not sure just how much the game truly represents evolution as biologists think about it.

At a fundamental level the biggest stumbling block in learning about evolution is not the process – Darwin’s insight of random variation and selective retention is quite easy to understand cognitively. The challenge and difficulty that people face is in truly grasping the non-teleological nature of this process – the fact that it is not driven by a goal.

Spore on the other hand is driven by the choices made by the player. And it is here that it differs fundamentally from Darwinian evolution. I am reminded of a software program, Biomorphs, developed by evolution guru Richard Dawkins (that he included in his book The Blind Watchmaker). [Online versions of this game can be found here.] Even though Dawkins saw this game as an example of how initial conditions and randomness can lead to very different designs of two-dimensional creatures, critics of evolution argued that since the the user decided which shape would be the “seed” and which shape they would like this process to “lead to,” this software program actually made a case for Intelligent Design!

The same criticism can be labeled at Spore as well. And interestingly enough, Will Wright is the first to agree with this. In a previous NYTimes article (The Long Zoom) he said

I’ve had a few people ask me if I think Spore will help teach evolution, and the ironic thing is that, if anything, we’re teaching intelligent design.

In a series of previous postings I had raised the question of how does a technology become an educational technology (see here and here). It seems to me that a game such as Spore (or Dawkin’s creatures) needs the presence of an educated “other” (a teacher, a mentor, a parent, an expert) to highlight what parts match with evolutionary theory and which parts are fanciful creations of the game designers.

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Creativity in Teaching & Learning @ Mizzou

Creativity in Teaching & Learning @ Mizzou

I was recently invited to conduct a workshop for the Celebration of Teaching Conference at the University of Missouri around Creativity in Teaching and Learning. This was my first time at Columbia, MO and the conference organizers were wonderful. I did two versions of...

KJZZ interview on STEAM education

KJZZ interview on STEAM education

I was interviewed recently by Mark Brodie of KJZZ.org for a story titled: STEM Vs. STEAM: Educators Urge Adding The Arts To Classrooms. You can listen to the interview on their page by clicking on the link above, or the MP3 below. My piece comes in at around the 3:14...

Oh the Irony!

Astrological Magazine to close due to "unforseen circumstances." What could be funnier than that! I am including the screenshot above just in case the website goes down.

Happy Teacher’s Day (new ambigrams)

September 5 is Teacher's Day in India. It is celebrated on the birthdate of Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, Indian philosopher and statesman who was also the first Vice-President and the second President of India. He famously said, "teachers should be the best minds in the...

Miami / Globe Video Update

Miami / Globe Video Update

I had posted earlier about the work our design initiatives team is involved with at Miami Junior-Senior High School. Essentially the entire faculty and leadership at the school have taken on the challenge of re-imagining the 7/8 curriculum through an integrated...

Seeing mathematics everywhere…

Dame Kathleen Ollernshaw was deaf since the age of 8. Despite this she had an amazing life as a mathematician, amateur astronomer, politician (she served as mayor of Manchester as well as in the Thatcher administration) and mother. To learn more about her read this...

Education in a pandemic: A crisis & opportunity

Education in a pandemic: A crisis & opportunity

Last year I was in Israel to present at the Meital Conference. When I was there I was interviewed by Lior Detal, the education correspondent for TheMarker - which led to an article in the magazine. Earlier this year, once the COVID crisis was in full swing, I was...

Leigh Wolf @IgniteLansing

Leigh Wolf, my partner in crime as far as the MAET program goes, recently presented at Ignite Lansing. She talked about her two passions, teaching and food (not sure which order to place these). Specifically she talked about food photography and the connections she...

Bridging the theory/practice gap: A visual exploration

Bridging the theory/practice gap: A visual exploration

Theoretically there should a reciprocal relationship between Theory and Practice - but it is the gap that every academic bemoans. This posting is prompted not by any particular insight into these matters but rather to share a set of visuals (ambigrams, memes,...


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *